Jacob Black a much better character then Edward Cullen? - what makes a character 2 dimensional
I have to say. Jacob actually shortcomings and characteristics that make them able to say to the readers to him, too. We were all jealous, we all felt fear and anger.
Edward Cullen, I believe, a 2-dimensional character of the inner fangirl is created in Stephenie Meyer. Seriously, his character annoys me with Gary Stu-ness.
Opinions?
Tuesday, January 19, 2010
What Makes A Character 2 Dimensional Jacob Black A Much Better Character Then Edward Cullen?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Personally, I would choose Jacob because Edward's big mistake is an overreaction. It is in his nature to be too extreme. It is "all or nothing kind of person, so it is reasonable. At the beginning of the eclipse is over-protective. If the error of their ways, she goes too far in the opposite direction. It could mean a term such as once to have admitted his jealousy, and asked Bella to choose him instead deeper with Jacob View selected. Of course there are other issues that we need to this question. And if Jacob is better for them and what happens when Bella could have a meaningful life with him? when Edward Bella really want to give everything for the life of vampires exist, or is it better to have an election, knowingly? "Can you see the dilemma? part of Edward wants Bella Jacob choose.
Jacob was a tragic failure. He has a purpose and hope. The goal is to save the life of Bella. Their hope is that he will win his heart in the process. Failure in both. But this does not mean that he regrets tryingIng If I could do it again, would be the same. Jacob could not live with himself if Bella did not save his best, he knows it will hurt when you lose, but I'm not hurt worse if left untreated. That makes everything all right? Hell, no! But he was sixteen years old and make it anywhere. Those who are shocked by some of his tactics to consider his youth and the fact that all right. Bella is in love with him. (At the end is actually healthier to be aware, the more immutable the decisions.) So, like Jacob, because they do not have the baby Bella and Edward. Jacob knows that Bella is able to handle dangerous situations. I wish my friend treats me as a right of defenseless children?
Oh, I almost forgot. There is a problem with the election of Jacob. If Bella chose Jacob instead of Edward, who fear that later always the mark of Jacob. What if it signs on for another? Although Jacob said when he ImprintBella does not if the mark has not been completed, it would do just that: let Bella. It happened to Sam What makes you think that the situation would be different from Jacob? Nevertheless, I still think Jacob is the better choice for Bella.
Absolutely disagree. Edward clearly expresses his opinion, a pest "evil." He thinks he'll go to hell, experience anxiety and almost killed. I can only say that Edward is completely overwhelmed, or other depressed or in a book.
I also believe that Jacob is very flat. He is willing to hurt Edward and Bella get what he wants, what is wrong. It's like a small dog. Bella hurts and brings tears to my eyes several times to come crawling and then say, sorry. In addition, if Edward were injured, seek forgiveness and to kill Bella. Jacob is openly rude comments to Bella in Eclipse and then off to visit her when he knows she hates when he does.
Interesting question, though.
Post a Comment